Reading time: 3 minutes
It seems that the “the judge is biased against Scientology” defense won’t work.
In 2023, disgraced actor Danny Masterson was convicted on multiple rape allegations.
Now he’s desperately attractive his sentencethrowing everything at the wall until something sticks.
The appeals court doesn’t believe it.


He is serving 30 years to life in prison
Masterson, once famous for his role in That 70s showhe is serving a 30-to-life prison sentence.
That won’t change, the three-judge appeals court ruled.
The 2023 court found him guilty of raping two women at his Hollywood Hills home in 2003.
The jury deadlocked on charges that he raped his ex-girlfriend in 2001.
Masterson’s lawyers claimed that Judge Charlaine Olmedo had made statements indicating some sort of anti-Scientology bias during the trial.
The appeals panel found that the judge demonstrated “no animus or departure from neutrality toward Scientology.”
The organization itself was central to the case. The indictment showed that the victims, all former members of the Church of Scientology, had delayed reporting the incidents for fear of retaliation.
Prosecutors brought a former Scientologist to testify about the organization’s practices, including a rule that bars reporting such matters to police.
For Masterson’s legal team, the fact that the court allowed this meant that an anti-Scientology bias had tainted the entire trial.
(One wonders what the defensive strategy is to argue that the predatory organization to which the convicted rapist belongs, the one he used to silence his victims while he searched for others, also created a prejudice against him and should therefore invalidate his conviction.)
“The admission of Scientology evidence for such purposes did not contravene the First Amendment”
In the 89-page ruling, the appeals court explained that the discussion of Scientology was relevant to the case and not a First Amendment issue.
“In this case the jury was not asked to determine the truth or falsity of Scientology doctrine or beliefs,” the court noted.
As such, the commission determined: “The admission of Scientology evidence for such purposes did not contravene the First Amendment.”
The court also ruled on statutes of limitations, evidentiary rulings and even the wild claim that Masterson had inadequate legal representation in the first trial.
None of these rulings were in Masterson’s favor.
There are countless real-life examples where a defendant’s religion is mentioned in court, casually or verbosely, in order to prejudice the jury and skew the trial in favor of the prosecution.
This can happen with an innocent person or with someone as guilty as Masterson.
There are minority religions whose organizations are under surveillance in America simply because they exist. In particular, but not exclusively, Islam.
However, if the perpetrator and the victims are all part of the same organization – known for massive retaliation against internal and external criticism – then knowing that organization’s tactics and how it might protect an evil man is very important to the case.
It is sad and disgusting to see, once again, people resort to real injustices – the marginalization of minority faiths and their adherents – in an attempt to let a bad man out of the prison cell where he belongs.
Download the app: Celebrity news firstPush alerts as soon as a story is interrupted · 4.8★ · Free
Get the application


