Despite its extended runtime, the episode ended without a murder or exile, leaving us with a huge number of questions.
We didn’t find out whether the celebrities were better than previous contestants at writing down each other’s names during the roundtable, or whether there would be another epidemic of players saying to each other, “I’m voting for you.”
But we know there will be drama. “Did the roundtables get heated? Yes,” Winkleman said.
“They’re polite, but they want to catch traitors, and traitors want not to be caught, and both sides are excellent at what they do.”
Sir Stephen’s total rejection of the “instinct” tactic was particularly refreshing.
“The idea that you can be good at reading people is complete nonsense, and it’s just like astrology or anything else,” he said before heading to the castle. “Woo woo. You can’t do this.
“We can all be convinced, even if the facts tell us otherwise. These ideas of ‘I just knew it, it’s the way he raised the glass, his eye did that thing’ – all nonsense.”
As the episode drew to a close, the most pressing question was which star Carr would kill in plain sight.
“I can’t believe they let me do this,” he said. “There are people I want to kill, but it won’t be easy. What will I do?”
We can’t wait to find out.
The Celebrity Traitors is on BBC One on Wednesdays and Thursdays at 9pm BST and onwards BBC iPlayer. There will be nine episodes.