Kanye West performs live. Photo credit: Kenny Sun
A copyright lawsuit over a paparazzo video? Celebrity photography company Bauer-Griffin is suing Gamma, its subsidiary Vydia, French Montana, Kanye West and others for allegedly incorporating a West rant caught on camera into a track without permission.
This outburst was recorded 13 years ago, when West and Kim Kardashian were walking toward the street from what appeared to be an underground parking garage. The paparazzi were positioned in said street – and in perfect place at that point – as West advanced with his gaze fixed on the ground.
Evidently, the stage was set for a viral moment: West ran straight into a sturdy sign, hitting his head with a thudand then got really frustrated when the press kept shooting (and recording) amidst the painful moment.
A consequent exchange with a photographer, whom West approached and asked in colorful language to stop taking photos, caused a sensation in the media.
A decade and a change later, the headache is gone in one sense but continues to throb in another.
Two years ago, French Montana incorporated audio from the incident into “Where They At,” released February 27, 2019 Mac and cheese 5 and presents the West; the seemingly inconsequential decision is actually significant.
Under US copyright law, when you photograph a celebrity in public, he or she (the photographer) owns the rights to the image. Head injury or not, the captured subject (and others) must obtain a license if the target legitimately uses the work.
Because of this fact and the ease with which social media posts can be published, there have been numerous infringement claims in recent years centered around the alleged unauthorized use of photos and videos by celebrities.
Now, we can add a particularly unique complaint to the list, as Bauer-Griffin, which bills itself as “a leading celebrity and breaking news agency,” is suing for alleged “flagrant and deliberate infringement” of the video and specifically the audio contained therein.
Like similar outfits, there isn’t much depth the simple actionwhich was brought to a federal court in California. As Bauer-Griffin sees the situation, the defendants lifted the audio despite knowing (thanks to their first-hand experience with copyrights) that they “had to have, but didn’t have permission” to do so.
Furthermore, the defendants – including producers Dem Jointz and BoogzDaBeast – would have “acted recklessly” with their “deliberate and intentional conduct”.
All told, Gamma, Vydia, Dem Jointz, and BoogzDaBeast are being sued for direct infringement, with West and Montana facing an indirect infringement claim. And on the compensation front, Bauer-Griffin is seeking an injunction blocking the continued use of the audio in “Where They At,” as well as a mountain of damages and “all profits” from the track.