“I killed them all, of course.”
OK, so we don’t quite understand a confession from Bob-Durst at the urinal new outside Peacock documentary series OJ’s accomplicebut directors Ari Marco (Amy Bradley is missing) and Sumit David (Diddy: The Creation of a Bad Boy) captured an interesting hot-mic moment of theirs during production.
The two-part docuseries resurfaces the somewhat forgotten alternative theory that OJ Simpson was aided by another man in the 1994 killings of former football star Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman’s ex-wife. (Simpson was acquitted of the double murder, but counterpoint: be serious.) The prime suspect in that alternative theory is now Joey Ippolito, a former drug trafficker and friend of Simpson’s. Simpson and Ippolito are both deceased.
One of the key characters – and “characters” is definitely the right term for the participants in this particular project – in OJ’s accomplice is Charlie Ehrlich, another friend of Simpson’s and another ex-convict. Ehrlich posed for the Ample Entertainment cameras at the strip club he runs, The Peppermint Hippo. Once the conversation was over, David told Ehrlich that the production would need to “get some B-roll,” and then both men headed to the bar. Ehrlich was still under the microphone and has now relaxed.
“You didn’t bring it up, so I’m not going to bring it up,” Ehrlich, who was still wearing a microphone and in the camera’s frame, told David from his stool.
And then he definitely talked about it.
“But yeah. I was really good friends with his brother Lou (Ippolito),” Ehrlich continued. “You know what Lou told me? He told me that a month before Joey died, he took him to Italy, he took Joe to Italy. Joe admitted to being involved [in the Simpson/Goldman murders].”
The Hollywood journalist asked Mark if Ehrlich was aware that his audio was still being captured.
“He knew he was being miked,” Mark said The Hollywood journalist. “What happens quite often is, you know, people are miked and they get comfortable. I don’t think he forgot that he was necessarily miked, but I think he probably started talking more casually.”
Mark says he also believes Ehrlich knew the cameras were still rolling.
David wasn’t the first person Ehrlich told Lou Ippolito’s story to. For starters, Mark said Lou Ippolito told the production the same story, just not on camera. (Ample Entertainment captured some footage of Lou Ippolito, but asked them not to use it, Mark said THR.)
But Ehrlich also has a big mouth, if you haven’t figured it out by now.
“It was like a deathbed admission. Louie told Charlie, Charlie told me,” Ehrlich’s friend Joe Spitaleri says in a separate statement OJ’s accomplice interview. “I was afraid to talk about it because Charlie asked me not to.”
Charlie broke his own rule, then.

Simpson in court in 1994.
POOL-/AFP/Getty Images
Not everyone can’t wait OJ’s accomplicewhich premieres both episodes Sunday morning on Peacock.
In an email sent earlier this month to THR (and other outlets), Joey Ippolito’s widow, Nicole Ippolito, ripped OJ’s accomplice as a “woefully misguided project.”
“The real facts demonstrate that this is another hoax fueled by those who are not here to defend themselves,” Nicole Ippolito wrote, calling the docuseries’ sources “con artists” and “drug addicts” who participate as a “money grab.”
Marco tells THR Ehrlich was paid only for the rights to the photographs and archival materials, which is a standard arrangement for documentaries. He was not paid for an interview.
THR attempted to contact Nicole Ippolito for comment.
At the time of Nicole Ippolito’s protest, OJ’s accomplice it was scheduled for release in December. Last Tuesday the plans were changed.
“We wanted to make sure this documentary remained part of the timely conversation of the news cycle,” a Peacock representative said THRreferring (mostly) to A New York Times item which covers the same theory using much of the same source material.
The timing of the article was not optimal OJ’s accomplicealthough it gives some credence to its newsworthiness. THR he asked Mark if being caught like that was “a shame.”
“Look, I mean, I’m always trying to juggle my ego with the success of a show, and over the years I’ve definitely gotten used to — and I say this not bitterly — but I’ve gotten pretty used to not getting credited for hard work,” he said. “It’s not a new thing for me. So, you know, I think the disappointment was not being able to pull it off the way I would like, taking away the credibility that the New York Times leads to this.”
Mark says he helped with the NOW piece. He would have appreciated greater collaboration for a coordinated release.
THR asked Mark what he personally believes happened on the evening of June 12, 1994. He definitely believes that Simpson was primarily responsible for the murders, which Mark says were more “premeditated” than most people think. For any “objective” person, he added, that’s more “logical” than believing Simpson had an aide at the scene.
OJ’s accomplice is now available to stream on Peacock.