After Luigi Mangione was arrested in December 2024 in relation to killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, the Internet did what it often does: it made something serious in a joke.
Almost two years later, on August 14, 2026, Mangione pleaded guilty to federal stalking charges and admitted to shooting Thompson. He is now contesting second-degree murder and related charges in New York state, where his trial is on hold while his lawyers argue much of the matter. the case should be dismissedstating that his federal guilty plea means New York would punish him twice for the same conduct.
After Mangione’s appeal, US Attorney Jamie McDonald said so “There can be no celebrity in assassination.”
Nonetheless, Mangione became a celebrity.
Viral memes, in 2024 and now, have romanticized him as a popular… and incredibly attractive – man of the people who did business the elites of the American health insurance industry are afraid.
Some of these memes adhered to conventional forms of political satire. One, for example, quoted a speech from the movie “A Bug’s Life”, in which an evil grasshopper argues for punishing the film’s protagonist ant to keep the other ants in line. In this meme, the political point was clear: elites preserve power by making an example of insignificant ants who dare to challenge them.
The point was less clear with other memes, including celebrations of chained ankles in Mangione fashion in court and Fake Burger King ads referring to the fact that a McDonald’s employee had been the one to call law enforcement: “Burger King: We won’t turn you over to the feds.” Rather than being ironicthey are not serious.
However, memes like these have received serious reactions social commentators AND political experts who interpreted them as evidence that young American adults are nihilistic and morally indifferent.
Like a experimental psychologist Who studies moral judgments about real-world controversiesI examined these attitudes towards Mangione and the humor surrounding him online.
I believe these reactions are best understood not as a rejection of values, but as a refusal to participate in conversations that seem selective and disconnected from the broader economic and political frustrations of young people. In my opinion, Generation Z’s dark and nonsensical humor does not show a lack of moral values, but is instead the product of their desire to engage in more authentic conversations about what they believe.
Alienation, not indifference
Research shows deep levels of alienation Between Generation Zthat is, young people born between 1997 and 2012. Having grown up with smartphones and social media, this generation has come of age in an increasingly online world. Despite the Internet’s ability to interact instantly, followers have proven to be a poor substitute for friends.
Gen Z is among the most socially isolated and psychologically distressed recorded generations. Compared to previous generations, many young adults have abandoned fewer friendships and romantic relationships longing for connection and solidarity. This alienation is evident in theirs too skepticism towards institutions and traditional narratives about values.
Many are pessimistic about achieving the goal American dream AND question the value of higher education. What was once considered the optimal vehicle for living a better life is instead seen as a barrier.
If the American dream seems out of reach and college seems like an expensive obstacle, they may feel called to take it seriously inauthentic, alienating and absurd.

AP Photo/Seth Wenig
When seriousness is suspended
Discussions about values require a certain seriousness if they are to resonate with their audience.
If, for example, a speaker who praises the value of artificial intelligence is met with ridicule from graduates – as was former Google CEO Eric Schmidt in May 2026 – the speaker’s message is immediately rendered inert.
These students’ taunts failed to offer an argument against the speaker’s claims; on the contrary, they created an atmosphere that prevented such claims from being taken into consideration. For graduates pessimistic about the implications of artificial intelligence for the labor market, claims professing its value seem inauthentic.
Together, their mockery not only provided an escape from what felt like an alienating and inauthentic message about the value of artificial intelligence, but also created a sense of solidarity through a shared suspension of seriousness.

AP Photo/Stefan Jeremiah
Humor offers an escape
Far from being a phenomenon exclusive to Mangione, this suspension of seriousness recurs throughout online meme culture.
THE OceanGate implosion suggested similar memes, including one depicting a pod of killer whales with the caption “The water is safe, send more billionaires.”
The assassination of Charlie Kirk also became material. In a trend known as “Kirkification,” users superimposed his face onto images ranging from the Mona Lisa to women in bikinistransforming a sad event into a shared absurdity.
In my opinion, Gen Z’s creation and circulation of memes offers an escape from otherwise serious conversations – for example, conversations about the value of The life of the CEO of UnitedHealthcare. This may be especially true when calls to convict Mangione appear to ignore inequities within the American health insurance system perceived as corrupt and unfair.
While commentators often dismiss Gen Z humor as… senseless or nihilistic meme slopstudies suggest that it acts as a collaborative coping mechanism, driven by the desire for authenticity.
Meme about Mangione, or even campus lookalike contests centered on him, fail to offer a precise moral argument in favor of a broad suspension of seriousness.
This style of humor can be seen in Mangione’s decision to leave a backpack containing Monopoly money in Central Park. It was also seen on shell casings recovered after Kirk’s killing, which included video game commandsa sexually suggestive internet saying and “if you read this you’re gay lmao”.
Incorrect explanations of nihilism
With the help of about a dozen college students, I examined the psychological and situational factors associated with Gen Z’s reactions to Mangione and other events, such as the Kirk assassination and the Kamala Harris is the “brat” phenomenon during the 2024 presidential elections – in two studies currently under review.
Our results indicate that favorable attitudes toward Mangione were associated not only with superficial factors, such as his perceived attractiveness, but also with higher levels of political cynicism.
Perceived systemic bias in the American justice system, for example, was addressed in a meme depicting Mangione entering the court with the lyrics “You can kill dozens of children and get a lesser sentence because their lives don’t matter as much as that of a CEO.” Federal prosecutors were seeking the death penalty against Mangione over an accusation made against a judge fired in January 2026.
Viewing Gen Z reactions as nihilistic obscures the values and institutional distrust associated with them and fails to appreciate their potential. egalitarian and pragmatic ideals. Firing them can deepen the alienation that allowed the death of a father of two children become a joke.

AP Photo/Yuki Iwamura
Because simple moral messages alienate
Although political commentators disagree on how to interpret the response to Mangione, many accept a seemingly basic principle: killing should never be justified.
Yet decades of research on moral judgment shows that people do not apply this principle consistently. Instead, in certain situations, as in the famous “trolley problem”, people frequently judge the murder morally permissible – especially when that killing is expected to promote the well-being of others.
Simplistic and sweeping moral injunctions not only fail to appreciate people’s actual moral attitudes, they also eliminate the possibility of having authentic, nuanced conversations.
Such conversations need not end up endorsing Mangione as a sympathetic figure. However, an open and authentic conversation about Mangione cannot take place in spaces that require reducing all discussion about the event to statements that, as has been argued by some”Murder is a bad thing. Period.”
Such requirements can make conversations about significant moral issues – even controversial ones, such as the morality of Mangione’s actions – little more than demands for compliance. In this case, these boundaries risk being ignored and, therefore, further alienating Gen Z.
Reactions to recent coverage illustrate this concern. A popular Reddit post published immediately after the guilty plea he complained that “media companies don’t report his entire statement,” referring to Mangione’s account in court of UnitedHealthcare who responded to his email within an hour when he introduced himself as a potential investor – in contrast, he said, to his previous dealings with insurers. In my opinion, these reactions are revealing: users were not necessarily upset that Mangione was portrayed negatively, but this information they considered relevant to understand his motivation he was excluded from the conversation.
Time will tell whether Mangione will be remembered, as his critics expect, as little more than a morally bankrupt flash in the pan or, those who support himas a martyr who reinvigorated a long-standing debate about health care in the United States
I believe the outcome will depend not only on the values of Gen Z, but also on how young people experience the conversational spaces in which Mangione’s crime, motivations and punishment are discussed. If these spaces are perceived as selective or inauthentic, continued alienation can make them laugh when seriousness is most required.
Utah Valley University undergraduate student Sebastian Trias contributed to this research.
This is an updated version of a story first published on August 6, 2026.